Originally Posted by
Diamondback
I also sent that chart to Rob and Andrea at Ares in the hope that maybe it will help keep scale in focus when/if they come back to Napoleonic. As it is I'm tempted to work up a cross-reference chart indexing everything in BWAS/FWAS to Ares models and Turner/Mann/other 3rd-party sculpts. (Side note, I really wish the Sails-oriented 3p's would coordinate efforts to plug more holes faster and avoid duplication of effort.)
My commentary to Ares: "Victory, Elizabeth, Eagle and Bristol are all covered by existing models and Falcon is IIRC covered by Swan, Princess Royal as a typical 900-ton EIM is probably statistically similar to the Groignard 900's like pre-refit BHR. Brilliant and similar 12pdr 36's are probably reasonably close to SGN101/103 anyway (frankly, most of us on the Stats Committee treat the Concordes as "statted as 36's" anyway) and I think could be represented by the SGN103 Amazon sculpt, so that leaves the 44-gun Roebuck two-decker (gesturing frantically at HMS Serapis) and the 20-24-gun light Sixth Rates as the sticky spots since we can just use a watered-down Amazon for a 28. Actually, maybe not even that--we usually treat most Swan as the 16's they were uprated to and Thorn as the 20 that was her heaviest refit, so maybe in math terms the smallest Sixths should just be a slightly juiced and bit beefier version of Thorn's basic stats."