PDA

View Full Version : Davids Vs Goliath



McDorf
10-12-2019, 13:20
Hello!

I was visiting a friend today and took my sails game. We decided to crack it open and have a small game.

The same started with them sailing 3 frigates: HMS Fairy, HMS Meleager, and HMS Sybille
I was flying French colours, on the Ship of The Line: Orient.
46274

The wind was in the favour of the Royal Navy, as both sides closed in ready to clash.
46275
46276

Disaster struck for both parties, shortly after closing the distance, a collision between HMS Sybille and the Orient. To which the rigging became entangled!
46277
46278

Shortly afterwards HMS Meleager managed to fire off a double loaded shot from their rear arc! Not doing much to the Orient's hull integrity, but certainly showing many Frenchmen the might of the Royal Navy!
46279

The captain of the Orient demanded to return fire, onto the smaller British Frigate. Dealing a substantial amount of damage, to the ship and her crew.
46280

Shortly after HMS Sybille and Orient untangled their rigging, and moved on... they became entangled again. And this time, both sides decided to board to the other ship.
Seems like the Orient's crew, though larger in numbers, cannot compete to their Royal Naval counterparts; who managed to kill of 2 sections of Frenchmen, and only losing a section of their own!
46281

After escaping the entanglement, and disengaging the boarding parties, they managed to break free...

HMS Syiblle seeing the chance to fire from her rear arc, a rear raking shot, loaded with double onto the Orient.
46282

However, the Orient returned the favour.
46283

Once they managed to FINALLY sail apart from each other, the Orient found the HMS Fairy nearby... and with a single double loaded shot from her rear arc, turned her into scrap.
46284
46285

In the meantime, HMS Sybille sailed off the end of the world, came back, and then sunk.
46286
46287
46288

HMS Meleager swooped back into action to avenge the lost ships that were lost to the might of the Orient.
46289

Shortly the Orient managed to swing her about to try and finish the job and claim victory for the French Navy... which didn't work too well.
46290

Until HMS Meleager thought they had scared off the Orient, firing off the first full broadside of the game. Not doing an awful lot of damage to the Meleager.
46291

A sudden boarding action took place, with what little crew was still going on the Orient daring to take on the Royal Navy yet again.
46292

A lesson the French didn't learn, all the crew on board had fought gallantly, but to no avail.
46293

The British had claimed the most marvellous prize, the Orient... she may have been greatly damaged and just about afloat, but this would be a prize any captain would be highly decorated for bringing home.
But on the other hand, the British had also received many losses. Was claiming the Orient worth the risk and losses the British took?

Vagabond
10-13-2019, 02:11
An unusual action? But a very close game, sounds like it might be fun, I must give this a go.
Cheers

Comte de Brueys
10-13-2019, 02:17
Great AAR, Gary! :salute:

TexaS
10-13-2019, 03:07
Nice battle.

McDorf
10-13-2019, 14:36
Thanks all!


An unusual action? But a very close game, sounds like it might be fun, I must give this a go.
Cheers

They had the starting set and a few British frigates, as I lack some French ships, I could have used my British frigates. So we agreed that I'd use my Ship of The Line, and see how interesting it would have played!

Bligh
10-14-2019, 01:08
Nice one Gary.
Thanks for this AAR.
An unusual set of circumstances as the chaps say but very interesting as it developed.
Is this your first AAR on the anchorage as games master?
Rob.

TexaS
10-14-2019, 04:25
There are kind of historical precedents to this. There’s the action of 13 January 1797. Kind of your own version of that.

Capn Duff
10-14-2019, 07:46
An unusual scenario but enjoyable to read, well done that man.
Just one rules point to remember, any raking shot has to be fired from the full broadside, you dont get raking shots using the half battery arcs.

Ferrante
10-18-2019, 07:31
I enjoyed a lot reading This battle report
Thank you

McDorf
10-25-2019, 02:30
An unusual scenario but enjoyable to read, well done that man.
Just one rules point to remember, any raking shot has to be fired from the full broadside, you dont get raking shots using the half battery arcs.

Cheers Chris.
I couldn't quite remember how the raking shots worked, so I allowed this for both sides. I think I did bend/change some of the rules just to keep things going and keep it short.


Nice one Gary.
Thanks for this AAR.
An unusual set of circumstances as the chaps say but very interesting as it developed.
Is this your first AAR on the anchorage as games master?
Rob.

This is indeed my first AAR here, and my first time being the game master for sails.

Bligh
10-25-2019, 07:08
I had a feeling it was your first outing into this field Gary.
Well done and keep up the good work.
i look forward to your next outing with much anticipation.
Meantime, I await my next encounter with the good Captain Kiwi.
This is due on Monday and I expect him to take me apart again as usual.
Rob.