PDA

View Full Version : Spanish Tresure Galleon vs. Royal Navy (by Hobbes)



Hobbes
07-29-2014, 11:14
I took a slightly different approach to my AAR. I hope you like it.

The following documents are excerts of communcations between various officers of the Royal Navy regarding an encounter between HMS Juno, HMS Terpsichore against Buque de Plata.

The initial order to Commodore Sebastian Hobbes

10852

After reaching the designated area, Commodore Hobbes opened the detailed orders (basically a narrative of the scenario, you don't have to read it).

10851

For some reason, I cannot delete the first version of the orders from this post, please forgive me.

Hobbes
07-29-2014, 11:14
On November 5th, HMS Juno under Command of Captain Jonas Rose encountered the Buque de Plata. Luckily HMS Terpsichore was present on the scene.

This is the report of Commodore Hobbes to his superior Admiral Collingwood.

10853

Here is the enclosed report from Captain Rose on the initial situation:

10854

Hobbes
07-29-2014, 11:15
Some infos on the actual game I played,

I started yesterday evening and played about 9 turns before giving it a rest.

In order to create the situation described in the above letters, I chose the starting position of the Buque de Plata and the orientations of Juno and Terpsichore randomly. I played with the standard rules, planning two movements in advance and so far only using ball shot. Despite some heavy navigational erros, the situations favours the British at the moment. We will see how this develops.

Hobbes
07-29-2014, 11:15
Apperently, the HMS Terpsichore recorded the fighting and drew some graphics:

10970

10971

Hobbes
07-29-2014, 11:15
10972

10973

10974

Hobbes
07-29-2014, 11:16
Res 5

spiessbuerger
08-10-2014, 14:56
Nice presentation and a lot of raking shots in that battle. That hurts
By the way: which tool did you use for?

Nightmoss
08-10-2014, 15:14
Very well reported!! I especially like the graphic 'top down' mapping of the battle. In many ways this is a much cleaner and clearer way to show how the battle unfolded. Like Matthias I'd definitely like to know which tool you used to make this display? :thumbsup:

Comte de Brueys
08-13-2014, 02:25
Nice new way of presentation, Hobbes.

As i read in the report you lost one of your frigates too, but captured the Spanish ship at last.

Well done, comrade. :salute:

Took you a lot of work, I guess. :wink:

fredmiracle
08-13-2014, 17:01
I absolutely loved this AAR--amazing! :thumbsup: :beer:

Hobbes
08-16-2014, 06:21
Thanks for the comments, I alos intended to write a London Gazette article, however, the birth of my daughter prevented me from doing this yet. I will see when I get the time.

I took top-down photos from almost each turn, then using Adobe Illustrator I traced the positions, At first I thought about showing the complete battle in one sketch. Unfortunatly, due to the heavy manouvering in the center of the map, nothing can be seen on that sketch.

My inability to bring Terpsichore into the battle early on, prolonged the scenario and the Juno payed the ultimate price.

If anyone of you is interested, I could send the AI or .svg files.

fredmiracle
08-16-2014, 11:47
Thanks for the comments, I alos intended to write a London Gazette article, however, the birth of my daughter prevented me from doing this yet. I will see when I get the time.


Congratulations! :beer:

Ducky
08-17-2014, 05:51
Great AAR really like the sketches!!!

Diamondback
08-17-2014, 23:23
Congrats, Sebastian!

Bligh
07-21-2015, 14:32
A very different presentation Sebastian, and very reminiscent of all the old sea warfare history books I used to read as a kid.
Very innovative.
Rob.